Why do so many organizations’ “suck” and why do they just not get “it” right?
Here’s a letter we received recently from a leader looking to us to take his organization up a degree or two (Make that at least five degrees!) When reading it, see if anything sounds familiar?
Dear Pathos,
I am writing to you after recently spending the last three days at a team building event my company held for its leadership development candidates (LDC). After three days of alternating excruciating heat (think James Arthur Ray’s sweat lodge) and freezing cold (think Donner Party), I am left wondering exactly why I was so excited to be selected as an LDC?
I guess at the heart of what truly bothers me is that as I looked around the room at the other LDC’s, I realized that each of us were really left to our own demise regarding how we performed our roles within the organization. Absent was any resemblance of consistency regarding our organization vision, picture of where we were going and values which would take us there. Worse yet, the leadership in our organization put on what could only be described as a “cold, distant, and disconnected” panel session in which we were encouraged to listen to their stories about how great the company was back in the 90’s!
I’ve come to the realization that “What got me here isn’t going to keep me there!” I feel disillusioned after my three days in close quarters with the organization’s leadership, a lot like Dorothy realizing that the Great Oz was actually just a man behind a curtain with some special effects! While I am grateful for the many things which the organization provides for me and my family, I worry about the cold culture causing lasting damage to me.
Cold Culture Survivalist
The letter from Cold Culture Survivalist prompted us to recall Dave Logan’s “Tribal Leadership” book in which he reveals that there are only 5 stages of organization culture, and that once you figure out where you are amongst those stages via what you have, you can determine how you can move up. Why would you want to move up in these culture stages? Well, according to Logan, the organization that do are more effective, more profitable, and basically everybody wins.
Here is a summary of the five stages identified in the book:
Bottom – Stage 1: (2% of all organizations) The bottom of the barrel, well to put it bluntly performs the least well. Here they say “life sucks!” They may not come out and say it out loud, but this screams from the participants actions. This happens rarely in the corporate world, but there are exceptions…
Stage 2: (25% of all organizations) “My life sucks” is their theme. No hostility, instead there is apathy. Performance drops, no innovation, new ideas are squashed, vision/values are laughed at (Mumbo jumbo), and so on is the way of life in this stage.
Stage 3: (48% of all organizations) Here they say “I am great, and you’re not!” There can be only one… very competitive here. In the end, you’ve got to look better. When it comes to clients, they notice that you’re not on the same page. If they only had a mirror to see themselves here in Stage 3!
From this point forward, organizations who operate in Stage 4 and 5 will reflect 300-500% improvement…
Stage 4: (23% of all organizations) “We’re Great, and They’re Not!” is the mantra here. There is always a competitor, as you move to the top of the organization; the “they” gets more vague.
Stage 5: (2%) Atop the Winslow Hierarchy of Needs is the idea that “Life is Great”… Our competitor becomes an idea, or a thought.
So what can our friend Cold Culture Survivalist do? Sometimes the realization of where you are truly at spending your time can be a valuable exercise. Here are several questions to ask yourself if you can sympathize with them:
- What stage do you believe your organization is at?
- What stage do you believe you are at within the organization?
- What are the “Top Three” actions within your control that you could take to improve the stage position?
- What’s at stake if you don’t achieve those three actions?
- What do you want to do?
▫ What’s your gut telling you is right?
▫ What’s your heart telling you is right?
Keep in mind, most leaders put themselves 2-3 stages higher than they really are (Positive Bias). Individuals aren’t very good at assessing themselves. The group is much better at assessing themselves, so perhaps you should also include feedback from those around you.
If you don’t get in touch with what’s really important to you, you will get yourself caught in one of those computer-programming-like loops we refer to as a “Downward-Death-Spiral.” This spiral sees nowhere but down-and-out as options. So how do you rewrite this? Confront Reality… or as one of our clients says “Decide… Commit… Succeed!”








